Dinner, a Show, and My Wife’s Hall Pass!
What do Keanu Reeves, Broadway, and some of the best Italian food we’ve had in New York City have in common? They all played a part in what turned out to be one unforgettable date night with my beautiful wife, Laila!
It all started when I decided to take Laila into New York City to see her “Hall Pass” man, Keanu Reeves, starring in Broadway’s limited engagement of Waiting for Godot, where he reunited with his Bill & Ted co-star Alex Winter.
Yes, ladies and gentlemen, I willingly took my wife to see the one man she’d probably leave me for. That’s how much I love this woman!
Now, basically being native New Yorkers, we couldn’t just go into Manhattan, see a Broadway show, and head home. That would practically be a crime against our upbringing! We needed to complete the experience with a proper New York City dinner near the Theater District.
Besides, this was another opportunity to impress the woman of my dreams…..Again!
After doing some research, I stumbled upon a relatively new Italian restaurant called Bucatini, located on East 45th Street, just a couple of blocks from the theater.
And boy, did I hit the jackpot!
First Impressions: Italian Elegance Meets New York City
Bucatini isn’t just another Italian restaurant in Manhattan. It’s an experience that combines Old World Italian charm with the sophistication and energy of New York City.
At the helm of the kitchen is Executive Chef Augusto “Guto” Ferreira, whose impressive culinary background includes acclaimed New York restaurants Socarrat and Intermezzo. Known for his creativity, discipline, and refined approach to flavor, Chef Guto brings Italian traditions into the modern dining world without losing the soul of the cuisine.
The restaurant itself is a work of art. Designed by Roy Nachum, founder of Mercer Project, the dining room blends artistic textures, dramatic lighting, and contemporary elegance to create an atmosphere that feels both luxurious and inviting.
When we walked through the doors, my first thought was, “Are we underdressed?”
Seriously, this place screamed class!
But then I remembered we were in New York City, where you can find someone wearing a $5,000 designer suit sitting next to someone who looks like they just rolled out of bed.
And honestly, nobody was looking at me anyway. They were too busy looking at my beautiful wife, who fit the elegance of the room perfectly.
We were like a real-life Beauty and the Beast.
I’ll let you figure out who’s who.
Since our Broadway show ended early, we arrived before the dinner rush, which gave us a chance to really take in the restaurant’s atmosphere.
Bucatini had only been open for a few months at the time of our visit, but judging by the ambiance and the menu, this place already knew exactly what it wanted to be.
And once I opened that menu, I felt like I had been transported straight to Italy.
Let’s Talk About the Food!
One of the first things I appreciated about Bucatini was its menu.
Unlike some Italian restaurants that hand you a menu resembling a small novel, Bucatini keeps things relatively simple and focused.
And sometimes, less really is more.
Starting Strong: Tuna Tartare and Poached Pear Salad
We kicked things off with two appetizers that set the tone for the entire evening.
First up was the Tuna Tartare, featuring yellowfin tuna, ponzu sauce, sitting on crispy kataifi nests, avocado mousse, and Osetra caviar.
WOW!
This dish was literally a party in your mouth. Every bite delivered something different. The freshness of the tuna, the tanginess of the ponzu, the crunch of the kataifi, and the creaminess of the avocado mousse all worked together beautifully.
Then came the caviar, adding that extra touch of luxury.
It was one of those dishes where you immediately regret having to share.
Next was the Poached Pear Salad, made with mixed greens, chopped pear, Gorgonzola, caramelized walnuts, dried cherries, and sherry vinaigrette.
Now, Laila is the salad expert in our relationship. I usually let her handle that department because, quite frankly, she knows what she’s doing.
And once again, she knocked it out of the park.
The combination of sweet pears, tangy Gorgonzola, crunchy walnuts, and dried cherries was incredible. But the real star of this salad was the sherry vinaigrette.
That dressing was ridiculously good!
I’m pretty sure when our waiter returned to clear the plates, he caught me trying to lick the remaining dressing off mine.
Hey, don’t judge me. Good food deserves appreciation!
The Main Event: Pasta That Would Make Nanna Proud
We decided to skip the antipasti and pizza and head straight for the pasta.
I mean, the restaurant is called Bucatini, right? How could we not?
Laila ordered the Black Fettuccine with Shrimp, featuring squid-ink pasta, shrimp, cherry tomatoes, arugula, and a delicate white wine–tomato sauce.
She explained that she chose the dish because it reminded her of something her Nanna used to make for Christmas dinner.
Now, whenever food brings back memories of a beloved family member, especially someone who cooked with love, you know you’re dealing with something special.
After taking a few bites, Laila looked at me and said something that I think Chef Guto would consider one of the greatest compliments he could ever receive.
She hadn’t tasted pasta this good since her Nanna passed away.
Think about that for a second.
Food isn’t just about satisfying your hunger. It’s about memories, traditions, family, and those moments that stay with you forever.
For Laila, that dish brought a little piece of her childhood back to the table.
And that’s something you can’t put a price on.
As for me, I went with the restaurant’s signature Bucatini Al Gusto, featuring house-made bucatini with your choice of classic Italian sauces, including Vodka, Marinara, Alfredo, Aglio e Olio, Puttanesca, Carbonara, and Bolognese.
Naturally, I went with the Bolognese.
And let me tell you something.
THIS. PASTA. WAS. INCREDIBLE.
The house-made bucatini was perfectly prepared, wonderfully light, and practically melted in your mouth. The Bolognese sauce was rich, flavorful, and everything you’d expect from an authentic Italian kitchen.
Every forkful made me want another.
And yes, I got caught licking my plate again.
At this point, our waiter probably thought I hadn’t eaten in three days.
But that’s what great food does to you. It makes you forget your manners!
A Wine List That Gets Laila’s Approval
When it comes to wine, I usually defer to Laila.
She’s the one who really appreciates a great wine list, and if she gives a restaurant’s selection her stamp of approval, that’s saying something.
Bucatini certainly passed her test.
She was impressed not only with the selection but also with the knowledge of the restaurant’s sommelier, who clearly understood the wines and how they complemented the food.
A great Italian dinner deserves great wine, and Bucatini delivered on both fronts.
Saving Room for Something Sweet
Now, you didn’t think we were going to leave without dessert, did you?
Not a chance!
Especially when Laila spotted one of her favorite childhood Italian pastries on the menu.
She ordered the Sublime Sfogliatella, a traditional Italian pastry that brought back even more memories of growing up.
For those unfamiliar with sfogliatella, it’s a beautifully layered, flaky Italian pastry that’s as much about texture as it is about flavor and resembles a lobster tail.
Laila said it was a little burnt, but she absolutely loved it!
Once again, Bucatini managed to transport her back in time through food.
I went with the Bonet, which was smooth, creamy, delicate chocolate cake, and absolutely delicious.
But because we apparently hadn’t consumed enough food already, we also decided to share an Affogato, the classic Italian dessert featuring espresso poured over vanilla gelato.
Coffee and ice cream together? Whaaaaaaat?
Whoever came up with that combination deserves a standing ovation.
It was the perfect way to finish an already incredible meal.
The Final Verdict: Broadway-Worthy Italian Dining
By the time we finished dinner, Bucatini had officially earned a place among our favorite restaurants in New York City’s Theater District and it was completely packed.
From the moment we walked through the doors until our final spoonful of affogato, the entire experience was exceptional.
The atmosphere was elegant without feeling stuffy. The service was attentive, the wine selection impressed Laila, and Chef Guto’s kitchen delivered dish after dish that left us wanting more.
But what really made Bucatini special was how the food connected with us personally.
For Laila, it was the memories of her Nanna and the Italian dishes she grew up loving.
For me, it was watching my wife enjoy an incredible meal after spending the afternoon seeing her favorite Hollywood heartthrob on Broadway.
And somehow, I still managed to be the guy taking her home!
Now, let’s talk about the price.
Is Bucatini expensive? It’s definitely on the pricier side, but come on, folks. You’re dining in Midtown Manhattan, just steps away from Broadway. You’re not exactly expecting dollar-slice pizza prices!
For a special occasion, romantic date night, anniversary, or dinner before or after a Broadway show, Bucatini is absolutely worth considering.
Would we go back?
In a New York minute!
The next time we head into the city for a Broadway show, Bucatini will certainly be high on our list.
And who knows? Maybe next time I won’t get caught licking my plate.
Who am I kidding? Of course I will!
Until our next culinary adventure, remember…
It’s Our World, You Can Just Eat With Us!
Restaurant Information
Bucatini NYC
Location: East 45th Street, New York, NY — Theater District
Cuisine: Contemporary Italian
Best For: Romantic date nights, special occasions, pre-theater and post-theater dining
Our Standout Dishes: Tuna Tartare, Poached Pear Salad, Black Fettuccine with Shrimp, Bucatini Al Gusto, Sublime Sfogliatella
Price Range: Upscale NYC dining — expect to spend a little dough!
Website: www.bucatininyc.com
Our Verdict: A memorable Italian dining experience where sophisticated atmosphere, exceptional pasta, and a little Old World nostalgia come together beautifully.
Leave a Reply